Which
Insulation is Best?
The two
main insulating products in use today are fiberglass,
made from melted glass, and cellulose
made from recycled newspapers. Many insulating companies install
both.
Fiberglass insulation is made by melting glass or sand
and then spinning it into fibers, like making cotton candy.
The fibers are matted together in a large blanket that is
cut into smaller blankets or shredded for blown insulation.
About 20 percent of the materials that go in fiberglass insulation
are recycled glass and bottles.
Cellulose insulation is made from ground newsprint,
phone books and sometimes a small amount of cardboard. Added
chemicals repel bugs and prevent fire. Cellulose is available
both loose fill and blown; about 80 percent of its content
is from recycled products.
Does
one insulation make your home tighter than another? "Control
home air infiltration first by sealing. Cracks in the
home's structure, openings around pipes and wires and leaky
recessed light fixtures are good places to start," says Walton
EMC Member Services Representative David Foster. "Even though
wall-blown systems that mix fiberglass or cellulose with adhesive
do a good job of stopping air leaks, don't depend totally
on them for infiltration control."
There
are differences in cellulose and fiberglass. It takes a greater
thickness of blown fiberglass to get the same R-value (a measure
of the resistance to heat flow) as blown cellulose. This won't
be a factor in places like attics, where there's plenty of
room. If space is limited (like in walls or cathedral ceilings),
cellulose may be preferred.
Though
cellulose doesn't have to be as thick to reach a desired R-value,
it settles more than fiberglass when blown in. When installing,
add 20 to 30 percent more cellulose than the thickness you
ultimately want.
What
about safety? All loose fill insulation products must meet
minimum fire standards set by the Consumer Products Safety
Commission. Wear proper safety gear (dust masks or respirators,
safety glasses, gloves) during any insulation installation,
regardless of the product. Make sure to follow the manufacturer's
recommendations.
The most
important step in insulating is to do it. Adding cellulose
or fiberglass insulation saves money and make your home more
comfortable.
|